Page 18 - JSOM Fall 2025
P. 18

TABLE 3  Tourniquet Need for Tightening-System Use
                                        Arm, all applications of all tourniquets on all recipients
                                                                Group; no. of recipients
                                                   SICH    DNIPRO     PULS      Y&B      X8T       χ  p-value
                                                                                                    2
           1st occlusion occurred without tightening-system use  6  9  10        0         6         .009
           1st occlusion required tightening-system use  24   21       20        30       34
           1st occlusion occurred without tightening-system
           use and no tightening-system use required beyond   1  5      2       NA         4
           securing tightening system                                                                .159
           1st occlusion occurred without tightening-system use
           but required additional tightening-system use after   4  4   8       NA         2
           1st completion
           Additional tightening-system use after 1st completion  5  5  8        8         5
           No additional tightening-system use after 1st   24  25      22        22       35         .484
           completion
                               Arm, applications of tourniquets on 22 recipients who received each tourniquet
           1st occlusion required tightening-system use  2    6         7        0         3
           1st occlusion occurred without tightening-system                                       .026 (.015)*
           use and no tightening-system use required beyond   20  16   15        22       19
           securing tightening system
           1st occlusion occurred without tightening-system use
           but required additional tightening-system use after   1  4   1       NA         1
           1st completion                                                                            NA
           Additional tightening-system use after 1st completion  1  2  6       NA         2
           No additional tightening-system use after 1st
           completion                                5        3         6        6         3      .632 (.671)*
           1st occlusion required tightening-system use  16   19       16        16       19
                                        Thigh, all applications of all tourniquets on all recipients
           1st occlusion occurred without tightening-system use  0  0   0        0         0         NA
           Additional tightening-system use after 1st completion  11  9  8       15       28
           No additional tightening-system use after 1st   19  21      22        14       12         .001
           completion
                               Thigh, applications of tourniquets on 22 recipients who received each tourniquet
           Additional tightening-system use after 1st completion  8  7  7        11       17
           No additional tightening-system use after 1st   14  15      15        10        5      .010 (.460)*
           completion
          *P values before the parentheses are for χ comparisons for all five tourniquets; p values in parentheses are for chi-square comparisons for only
                                       2
          the four Ukrainian-manufactured tourniquets.
          SICH = Strengthened Individual Combat Hybrid Tourniquet; DNIPRO = TQ DNIPRO GEN 2; PULS = PULS Tourniquet; Y&B = Yellow & Blue
          tourniquet; X8T = X8T-T2G tourniquet; NA = not applicable.

          No X8T pressures were over 500mmHg. No arm occlusion pres-  pressures  (Figure  3A,  3B)  were  both  associated  with  need-
          sures were over 500mmHg (Figure 3A). Among the Ukrainian-   ing more total turns of the tightening system (circumference
          manufactured tourniquets, pressures over 500mmHg occurred   p<.0001, pre-tightening system use  p=.096 for  Y&B and
          in 39 arm first completions (9 SICH, 13 DNIPRO, 16 PULS, 1   p<.0002 for others, Figure 3C). Difficulty securing the Y&B
          Y&B), 49 arm pre-releases (12 SICH, 11 DNIPRO, 24 PULS,   rod in the triangle was caused by turn-related rod migration
          2 Y&B), 10 thigh occlusions (3 SICH, 4 DNIPRO, 2 PULS,   (Table 2).
          1 Y&B), 67 thigh first completions (19 SICH, 19   DNIPRO,
          18 PULS, 11 Y&B), and 83 thigh pre-releases (21 SICH, 22   The median (IQR) times from audible pulse detection to
            DNIPRO, 23 PULS, 17 Y&B) (Figure 3A, 3B).        hands-off after completion of an additional windlass-rod
                                                             turn were as follows: SICH 10 (9, 15) seconds (p=.028 versus
          Within each application across all five designs, 99 of 101 per-    DNIPRO, p=.005 versus PULS), DNIPRO 18 (13, 21) seconds,
          turn, after-first-completion pressure increases were greater than   PULS 17 (16, 20) seconds, Y&B 12 (11, 18) seconds (p=.058
          per-turn, first-completion pressure increases (Figure 3D). Arm   versus PULS, but does not include non-secured Y&Bs).
          applications generally had higher per-turn, first- completion
          pressure increases and higher per-turn, after-first- completion   Tourniquet Signs of Wear
          pressure increases than leg applications (Figure 3D). Compared   With 30 arm and 30 thigh uses for each Ukrainian- manufactured
          to the other tourniquets, Y&B per-turn pressure increases were   tourniquet, none became unusable. Each required resetting be-
          lower, and PULS per-turn pressure  increases tended to be higher.  tween uses, including thorough untwisting of the inner straps
                                                             of the SICH, DNIPRO, and PULS. Y&B resetting included flat-
          As expected, 17–19  larger circumference limbs required higher   tening of the fabric-enclosed, thin, small plate after most thigh
          pressures for occlusion (p<.0001 each tourniquet). Larger cir-  applications. The base plates of the  DNIPRO and PULS did not
          cumference limbs and lower achieved pre-tightening- system-use   require any repositioning as part of tourniquet resetting.

          16  |  JSOM   Volume 25, Edition 3 / Fall 2025
   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   23