Page 34 - JSOM Winter 2023
P. 34
<.050 TMT and Tac RMT versus each of others except p=.085 TMT versus SOFTTW3 <.008 Tac RMT versus each of others except TMT <.010 TMT versus CAT7, SOFTTW5, =0.113 TMT versus X8T; =0.097 TMT versus RST SOFTTW3 and Tac RMT; =.079 TMT CAT7, SOFTTW5, OMT, and X8T X8T; =.054 TMT versus CAT7; =.109 TMT versus SOFTTW3; =.063 TMT of others except TMT <.030 Tac RMT versus each of others except TMT <.030 TMT versus CAT7, SOFTTW5, =.088 TMT versus
P-values 1 and OMT; =.094 TMT versus SOFTTW3; <.030 TMT versus each of others except versus SOFTTW3; <.009 Tac RMT versus <.050 TMT versus SOFTTW5, OMT, and versus RST; <.040 Tac RMT versus each and OMT; =.118 TMT versus SOFTTW3; <.050 TMT versus each of others except versus SOFTTW3; <.020 Tac RMT versus <.020 Tac RMT versus CAT7, SOFTTW3, SOFTTW3, SOFTTW5, and OMT; <.008 SOFTTW3; =.110 X8T versus TMT; =.095 Tac RMT versus CAT7; =.078 SO
RST n=61 24.50 (21.15, 38.86) n=7 22.17 (20.76, 24.73) n=23 24.73 (21.82, 29.23) n=61 24.50 (21.15, 38.86) n=61 25.92 (21.59, 41.72) n=7 22.80 (21.32, 25.92) n=23 25.92 (21.87, 29.85) n=61 25.92 (21.59, 41.72) n=40 8.02 (6.01, 10.28) n=13 6.69 (4.87, 8.44) p=.991 versus RST Loose Strap n=27 8.77 (6.45, 11.50) p=.991 versus RST Tight Strap n=40 8.02 (6.01, 10.28) n=13 6.69 (4.87, 8.44) p=.991 versus
Tac RMT n=59 36.03 (28.09, 46.91) n=15 30.30 (27.24, 36.12) n=21 30.30 (26.46, 36.82) n=56 35.09 (28.07, 43.37) n=59 36.70 (28.90, 48.07) n=15 30.59 (27.89, 36.99) n=21 30.71 (27.38, 37.71) n=56 36.14 (28.90, 43.89) n=52 8.44 (5.75, 12.04) n=19 5.53 (4.55, 8.25) p=.039 versus Tac RMT Loose Strap n=34 9.80 (7.93, 12.96) p=.039 versus Tac RMT Tight Strap n=52 8.44 (5.75, 12.04) n=19 5.53 (4.55, 8.25)
X8T n=56 22.50 (19.77, 29.28) n=3 18.10 (16.04, 22.12) n=14 22.19 (16.31, 34.36) n=56 22.50 (19.77, 29.28) n=56 25.62 (21.39, 33.77) n=3 18.44 (16.77, 22.91) n=14 26.81 (18.02, 35.48) n=56 25.62 (21.39, 33.77) n=48 7.13 (4.82, 11.02) n=11 6.70 (4.62, 12.54) p=.999 versus X8T Loose Strap n=37 7.56 (4.83, 11.00) p=.999 versus X8T Tight Strap n=48 7.59 (4.87, 11.02) n=11 7.83 (5.22, 12.54) p=.982 versu
OMT n=56 26.03 (22.56, 31.07) n=12 23.41 (18.92, 28.39) n=45 26.20 (22.56, 30.85) n=39 25.62 (22.55, 31.29) n=56 28.48 (24.13, 33.38) n=12 25.94 (20.20, 29.39) n=45 28.34 (23.98, 33.32) n=39 28.63 (24.17, 33.19) n=51 6.22 (4.17, 8.12) n=40 5.32 (4.06, 8.01) p=.583 versus OMT Loose Strap n=11 7.70 (6.40, 8.40) p=.583 versus OMT Tight Strap n=51 6.22 (4.17, 8.12) n=40 5.32 (4.06, 8.01) p=.583 versus
TMT n=57 43.07 (34.21, 58.39) n=5 26.08 (23.09, 33.23) n=16 38.49 (29.46, 53.85) n=42 39.22 (32.85, 49.55) n=57 45.14 (35.29, 60.20) n=5 26.61 (23.80, 33.92) n=16 40.34 (33.19, 54.28) n=42 42.66 (34.57, 51.97) n=38 5.30 (4.64, 7.42) n=12 4.50 (3.49, 5.21) p=.558 versus TMT Loose Strap n=26 6.39 (5.10, 7.85) p=.558 versus TMT Tight Strap n=38 6.21 (4.97, 8.24) n=12 4.50 (3.49, 5.21) p=.389 versus L
TABLE 1 Median and Interquartile Times in Seconds According to Tourniquet
SOFTTW5 n=60 21.50 (17.81, 28.92) n=16 19.51 (16.20, 21.50) n=39 20.92 (16.57, 26.20) n=59 21.49 (17.81, 28.54) n=60 22.65 (18.52, 33.09) n=16 20.53 (16.64, 22.62) n=39 21.77 (17.27, 27.62) n=59 22.62 (18.51, 31.15) n=44 4.25 (3.60, 6.48) n=34 4.18 (3.48, 5.76) p=.076 versus SOFTTW5 Loose Strap n=10 6.51 (3.84, 9.63) p=.076 versus SOFTTW5 Tight Strap n=44 4.65 (3.88, 7.38) n=34 4.25 (3.87, 6.46) p=.
SOFTTW3 n=59 24.12 (19.97, 35.24) n=11 20.45 (16.93, 24.08) n=22 21.35 (17.64, 28.49) n=59 24.12 (19.97, 35.24) n=59 25.73 (20.37, 37.55) n=11 20.95 (18.16, 24.94) n=22 24.22 (18.94, 31.16) n=59 25.73 (20.37, 37.55) n=47 5.80 (4.52, 7.95) n=19 4.84 (3.98, 5.70) p=.564 versus SOFTTW3 Loose Strap n=28 6.47 (5.01, 8.16) p=.564 versus SOFTTW3 Tight Strap n=47 5.99 (4.52, 8.04) n=19 5.00 (3.98, 7.76) p
(21.26, 29.15) n=23 (21.71, 27.37) n=49 (21.26, 29.15) n=46 (21.55, 29.05) n=53 (22.30, 30.62) n=23 (22.47, 28.65) n=49 (22.30, 30.62) n=46 (22.31, 30.06) n=48 (3.12, 6.24) n=47 (3.12, 5.28) Strap n=1 12.10 Strap n=48 (3.15, 7.30) n=47 (3.14, 7.28) n=1 12.10 Tight Strap n=52 n=17 (10.47, 18.12) n=17 (10.47, 18.12) n=0 redirect (optimal strap pulling would be downward).
CAT7 23.74 25.02 23.74 24.27 25.48 26.89 25.48 25.59 3.97 3.90 p=.998 versus CAT7 Loose p=.998 versus CAT7 Tight 4.21 4.17 p=.998 versus Loose Strap p=.998 versus 12.26 (8.70, 15.71) 14.47 14.47
n=53
“Go” to “Strap Secured” (strap/redirect system) Good Orientation 2 “Go” to “Strap Secured” (strap/redirect system) Good All Aspects 2 “Go” to “Strap Secured” (strap/redirect system) Tight Strap 2 “Go” to “Strap Secured” (strap/redirect system) Secure Strap 2 “Go” to “Touch Tightening System” (strap/redirect system) Good Orientation 2 “Go” to “Touch Tightening System” (strap/redirect system) Good All Aspects 2 “Go” to “Touch Tightenin
32 | JSOM Volume 23, Edition 4 / Winter 2023 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.

