Page 36 - JSOM Winter 2019
P. 36

TABLE 13  CAT6 Pressures                           TABLE 15  CAT6 Complications and Safety
           Total                                              Total
           Score Score        Pressures       n =   Citation  Score Score   Complications and Safety  n =  Citation
                     322.91mmHg mean combined                           Unexposed CAT6 had 100%
                 5   pressures of all studies.  92  Combined            effectiveness (50 of 50 tests),
                     205mmHg in mean tourniquet                     3   whereas exposed devices had 82%   50  20
                 4                             10    18                 effectiveness (41 of 50 tests; p = .003).
                     pressure.
                 4   202mmHg mean pressure.    10    22                 Wet tourniquets neither prolonged
                                                                    5   application nor did they increase   46  25
                     Strap occlusion pressures of                       failure rates.
                     318mmHg (median), 260mmHg
                 4                             12    34                 Heat exposure was not associated
                     (minimum) – 536mmHg
                     (maximum).                                     5   with tourniquet damage, inability to   30  23
                                                                        gain hemorrhage control, or inability
                     Calf application – pressures at                    to stop the distal pulse.
           4.29  4   occlusion, completion, and 120   15  14
                     seconds after completion 382 ±                     CAT6 was the only tourniquet to
                     100, 510 ± 108, 424 ± 92mmHg.                      experience a mechanical failure. The
                                                                        failure occurred when the windlass
                     Forearm application – pressures                3   was tightened before adequate   40  27
                     at occlusion, completion, and 120
                 4                             15    14       3.25      tension was applied to the main
                     seconds after completion 301 ±                     strap.
                     100, 352 ± 112, 310 ± 98mmHg.                      Occlusion pressure decrease over
                     Occlusion completion pressure                      1 minute after occlusion of 44 ±
                     mean 360mmHg (147–                             1   33mmHg with 17 of 61 applications   61  35
                 5   745mmHg). Three CAT thigh and   61  35             requiring adjustment.
                     9 CAT arm completion pressures
                     were >500mmHg.                                     1 of 15 calf applications and 0 of 15
                                                                        forearm applications lost occlusion
                                                                    4                              30    14
                                                                        after 120 seconds from initial
          TABLE 14  CAT6 Specifications                                 occlusion.
           Total                                                        12% of tourniquets worn on plate
           Score Score        Specifications        Scoring         2   carrier and exposed to Afghanistan   400  29
                     Width – ≥1.5 inches (critical   1.5   1 – Yes /    elements broke on testing.
                 1
                     requirement).           inches  –1 – No            14/166 exposed versus 0/166
                     Length – ≥37.50 inches or                      3   Unexposed broke and had decreased  166  33
                 1   provide 35 inches circumferential   37.5   1 – Yes /    efficacy.
                     (critical requirement).  inches  –1 – No
            5                                      1 – Yes /    TABLE 16  CAT6 Usage
                 1   Locking Mechanism/Method.  Yes
                                                    0 – No    Total
                                                   1 – Yes /    Score Score         Usage              Citation
                 1   Time Recording.          Yes
                                                    0 – No              70% efficacy reported in 104 combat
                     Weight – <8 ounces            1 – Yes /        4   prehospital applications.        36
                 1                           2.7 oz
                     (critical for JFAK inclusion).  –1 – No        4   152 documented uses in combat.   10
                                                                    4   71 documented uses in combat.    37
                                                              3.40
                                                                        98% effectiveness (n = 61) reported in
                                                                    5   civilian multi-institutional study between   38
                                                                        2009 and 2014.
                                                                    0   No user preferences recorded.
                                                             TABLE 17  CAT6 Logistics
                                                              Total
                                                              Score Score     Logistics
                                                                    5   NSN in DoD System.  Same as CAT7
                                                              N/A   3   GSA Cost per Unit.  No longer sold as CAT6
                                                                    3   Commercial Cost per   No longer sold as CAT6
                                                                        Unit.



















          34  |  JSOM   Volume 19, Edition 4 / Winter 2019
   31   32   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   41